Once an Anchor Girl, Always an Anchor Girl

MISS
2014: Rose McClimans (4th Runner Up to Miss Indiana, Preliminary Talent Winner)
2015: Katelyn Marak (Winner of Joy of Life Scholarship; Finalist for Quality of Life)
2016: Melissa Smoker (Finalist for Quality of Life)
2017: Demie Johnson
2018: Madelyn Steurer (Top 11 Semi-Finalist, Arts in Action Dance Award)
2019: Amanda Fischer
2020/2021: Libbey Detcher

TEEN
2014: Kassidy Tharp (3rd Runner Up to Miss Indiana’s Outstanding Teen)
2015: Bailey Perez (2nd Runner Up to Miss Indiana’s Outstanding Teen)
2016: Taylor Lueking (Scholastic Achievement Award)
2017: Lily Padgett (Non-Finalist Interview Award)
2018: AnnaBella Brown (Scholastic Achievement Award)
2019: Emily Eshbach (Miracle Maker Finalist)
2020/2021: Alyssa McClendon (Did not compete at state)